
Bees, keys, doors, doorknobs, swords, a pirate, a girl, the Owl King, the moon, stars, fate, time, cats, the kitchen (who is the kitchen?!), a sea of honey, a sculptor who carves stories, mysterious doors with mysterious doorknobs, a secret society, and fairytales. Welcome to the satisfying world of Erin Morgenstern!
“Tonight is the last night.” (page 5)
The story begins with a prisoner (so referred to as a pirate), who is locked in a cell and visited by a girl who brings him food. Their silent interactions grow into a bond, and the bond soon turns into love. Their story ends with the only conversation they ever have, when she asks him to tell her a story and he obliges.
I expected the next chapter to tell me what happened next, or who the pirate and the girl were. It did not. To my surprise, the next chapter was an introduction to the Starless Sea, an underground library buried in a labyrinth of stories. And even that was not it. The book then introduces us to Zachary Ezra Rawlins, the protagonist and an avid reader, who discovers a mysterious book that tells him nothing about itself but contains an accurate account of an event from his childhood.
From there, Zachary becomes enmeshed in a battle to save the Starless Sea with the help of Dorian and Mirabel, against the Collector’s Club, a secret society led by Allegra that is resolute to destroy every door leading to it. What makes Allegra fascinating is that she doesn’t want to destroy the Sea. She loves it. She wants to seal it away so that its story never reaches an end, which makes her far more unsettling than a simple villain. All of this is coiled together with dozens of other narratives.
The adaptation of the ‘frame story’ was a good choice, but was it truly successful? A frame story is a technique wherein a story occurs within a story, that is, where multiple narratives exist within a larger plot. My answer: mostly, until the last stretch. In the first half, every fairytale and fragment felt like a clue, and I kept flipping back to see how each one connected to Zachary. Towards the end, though, the threads multiplied faster than they tied up, and the story became extremely complicated. The frame held, but only just.
The ‘use of symbols’ was yet another feature of the book. There is heavy usage of symbols such as the Owl King, the moon, stars, fate, bees, the kitchen, and several others, and their final interpretation is left to the readers altogether. The one that stayed with me was doors. As a child, Zachary finds a painted door and walks away from it, and in a way the whole novel is about that unopened door. A door is a promise that a story can begin. So when the Collector’s Club destroys doors, and keeps their doorknobs labelled like trophies, they aren’t just closing passages. They are refusing to let stories begin or end. Once I read the doors that way, the keys, the doorknobs, even the door that is delighted to be knocked upon after so long, all started to click.
Not every symbol needs decoding, though. Some lines are simply there to be felt:
Far above the stars are watching, delighted. (page 494)
This can be confusing and frustrating, and I won’t pretend otherwise. But I believe it is deliberate. The Starless Sea refuses to behave like the plot-driven fantasy it resembles. It asks to be read the way you would read a book of fairytales, piece by piece, trusting the pieces to add up, and with a little lack of focus the story can slip away from you entirely. Where this works, it truly works: I never needed anyone to explain the sea of honey or the bees, because the images were enough on their own. Where it doesn’t is the ending, where I wanted a little more of the author’s hand and a little less left to me. The multitudinous characters, each with a distinct narrative, add to the layers of the story, and occasionally to the tangle.
That is the aesthetic nature of the novel: stories of a lovelorn pirate and a girl, acolytes, the Starless Sea, and most importantly, the touch of modern magic, such as a masquerade party, a New York library, and a painted door in Central Park.
All in all, ‘How are you feeling?’ Zachary asks. ‘Like I am losing my mind, but in a slow, achingly beautiful sort of way,’ Dorian replies. (page 288) It is hours of delight loaded with honey and bees, and completely worth the bent spine 🙂
Laters!
Shreya is a lawyer & policy researcher with an affinity towards books, movies, and dogs, cats, cows.
